Let’s say my good friend casts Rite of Replication on certainly one of his creatures. Right after that, I play an instant–Flesh to Dust–and destroy his creature. Would that counter the sorcery?

If not, would I’ve to forged the moment proper when he casts Rite of Replication?

Or say one thing like “earlier than you forged that spell I’m destroying your creature…”

1

Yes, the Rite of Replication would fail in the event you destroy the creature it is focusing on. It performs out like this:

  1. Your opponent casts Rite of Replication focusing on their creature.

  2. You forged Flesh to Dust in response to Rite of Replication.

  3. Your Flesh to Dust resolves, and their creature dies.

  4. Your opponent’s Rite of Replication tries to resolve, however for the reason that creature it focused is now not on the battlefield, it would not resolve due to rule 608.2b, which says

    If the spell or capacity specifies targets, it checks whether or not the targets are nonetheless authorized. A goal that is now not within the zone it was in when it was focused is unlawful […] If all its targets, for each occasion of the phrase “target,” are actually unlawful, the spell or capacity doesn’t resolve. It’s faraway from the stack and, if it’s a spell, put into its proprietor’s graveyard.

6


You should log in to reply this query.

Not the reply you are in search of? Browse different questions tagged .