Home Puzzles Old music halls / THU 10-13-22 / Extended characteristic of “Hey Jude” and “Layla” / Congress-created media big / Churchill portrayer in 2017’s Darkest Hour / Mankind biblically / Jamaican sprinter Thompson-Herah / Fruit liqueur from Italy / Evidence supplier for some citations

Old music halls / THU 10-13-22 / Extended characteristic of “Hey Jude” and “Layla” / Congress-created media big / Churchill portrayer in 2017’s Darkest Hour / Mankind biblically / Jamaican sprinter Thompson-Herah / Fruit liqueur from Italy / Evidence supplier for some citations

0
Old music halls / THU 10-13-22 / Extended characteristic of “Hey Jude” and “Layla” / Congress-created media big / Churchill portrayer in 2017’s Darkest Hour / Mankind biblically / Jamaican sprinter Thompson-Herah / Fruit liqueur from Italy / Evidence supplier for some citations

[ad_1]

Constructor: Lewis Rothlein

Relative problem: Challenging

THEME: SKIP TOWN (62A: Run off … or the best way to make the solutions to 17-, 21-, 34-, 44- and 53-Across match their clues) — “skip” the title of a “city” (from the state in parentheses on the finish of every theme clue) to discover a common phrase, which is the reply to the clue. The precise reply you see within the grid? Completely unclued:

Theme solutions:

  • REBUTTED (17A: Sunset shade? (MT)) = RED
  • BLARED OUT (21A: Start of an objection? (TX)) = BUT
  • CHEERIEST (34A: Booty spot? (PA)) = CHEST
  • HOME SALES (44A: They’re the pits (AZ)) = HOLES
  • PROVOLONE (53A: Sole (UT)) = LONE

Word of the Day: ELAINE Thompson-Herah (64A: Jamaican sprinter Thompson-Herah with 5 Olympic golds) —

 

Elaine Sandra-Lee Thompson-Herah OD (née Thompson; born June 28, 1992) is a Jamaican sprinter who competes within the 60 metres100 metresand 200 metres. Regarded as one of many biggest sprinters of all time, she is a five-time Olympic champion, the quickest girl alive over the 100 m, and the third-fastest ever over 200 m. 

Thompson-Herah is the primary feminine sprinter in historical past, and the second sprinter after Usain Bolt, to win the “dash double” at consecutive Olympics, capturing 100 m and 200 m gold on the 2016 Rio Olympics and once more on the 2020 Tokyo Olympics. A six-time Olympic medallist, she rose to prominence on the 2015 World Athletics Championships, successful a silver within the 200 m. At the Rio Olympics, she grew to become the primary girl since Florence Griffith-Joynerin 1988 to win 100 m and 200 m gold on the Olympics. (wikipedia)

• • •

Much as I hate saying this (and I do), this was not pleasant to me in any respect. The theme did not appear to be enjoying truthful, and the “reveal” was fully deflating. The worst a part of all, from a puzzle-enjoyment standpoint, was that the solutions within the grid will not be clued. There is actually nothing pointing to them on the degree of which means or sense. This is an *particularly* galling downside when getting these solutions is so arduous. I’ve seen unclued puzzle components earlier than, however often they don’t seem to be your endpoint. They aren’t your aim. They’re incidental, otherwise you get them comparatively simply however do not fairly know why? But right here … a number of work for a solution with no obvious relationship to something. You need to put the themers collectively from a system … for no purpose. You simply do. There is not any thematic coherence to the set. What does REBUTTED need to do with BLARED OUT (an ungainly phrase to start with)? Nothing. At the extent of which means: nothing. None of the solutions have something to do with one another (on the definitional degree) and not one of the solutions are even clued (on the definitional degree). So you will have this extremely arduous activity of getting to determine what the system is for making the clues make any sense, after which you need to make a believable (once more, unclued) reply from that system. When I say that the puzzle wasn’t enjoying truthful, I imply not simply that the solutions are unclued, however that they’re unrelated to at least one one other. I used to be actually, actually anticipating the non-town components of the theme solutions to have *one thing* to do with one another. I by some means acquired REBUTTED (slowly, fully from crosses—had REBUTTAL in there at one level), after which thought “oh, okay, colours are concerned” (as a result of “BUTTE” appeared inside “RED”), after which … properly, the subsequent themer began “BL-” so clearly that was going to have one thing to do with “BLUE,” proper? Ugh, fallacious. With CHEERIEST I spotted that the container phrases, i.e. the literal clue solutions (RED, BUT, CHEST, and many others.), not like the “cities,” had been *additionally* not going to have something to do with one another. It’s simply arbitrariness after arbitrariness, and for an especially anticlimactic payoff. Anticlimactic on the degree of the person reply (“the reply to the clue .. is simply … BUT?”), and anticlimactic on the revealer (SKIP would not even precisely describe what’s taking place in each case—see under).

Add to all this the actual fact all of the clues within the puzzle really feel like they had been turned method up, difficulty-wise. It was such a slog. I really got here to a useless cease with your entire SW largely empty, questioning how on the earth I used to be going to get in. I had DONNE and RELO written in there and that is about it. Couldn’t get: SUITE, NPR (clue made it appear to be one thing I’d by no means heard of) (46A: Congress-created media big), TRAVAIL, RECIPROCAL, RADAR, MALTED (ugh), RECANT, ELAINE (simply did not know her), POLLED. But … and perhaps you’ll be able to see the place that is going … the true problem on this part: PROVOLONE. Why? Because “SKIP” implies “bounce over,” i.e. begin on one facet after which proceed on the opposite. But this reply Does Not Do That. The “reply,” LONE (53A: Sole), “skips” exactly *nothing*. You do not even take care of PROVO. It simply sits off to the facet, after which LONE comes after. That is just not “skipping.” And the letter mixtures in that phrase meant that despite the fact that I knew PROVO was the “city” concerned, I attempted to place PROVO in utilizing the “O”s from DONNE and HERO (i.e. the 2nd and third “O”s) as an alternative of these in RECIPROCAL and DONNE. And then after all could not make any reply match. And since, as we have established, the complete solutions are Completely Unclued … ugh. The solely pleasure I acquired from this puzzle was writing in YEA HIGH, which is a enjoyable factor to say (39A: “… about as much as right here”). The relaxation: a intentionally obtuse chore. I simply do not perceive the place the enjoyable is on this one. 

Had a number of fallacious solutions, like SOLO for CODA (1A: Extended characteristic of “Hey Jude” and “Layla”), and ODE for OED (15A: Meaningful work, for brief?). But primarily I simply could not get issues. I knew folks acquired their GEDS, however I did not know they’d “scores,” and boy does that look bizarre within the plural (40D: Their scores are on some coll. purposes). Speaking of abbreviations, it felt like an onslaught at instances. NBA OED BEEB ADDL is simply the densest instance. There’s different clusters too, like NCIS IFC. And NSFW WDS IDS. And it is not like there’s a number of pretty fill to make up for it. I had this theme that was sluggish and ugly to unravel, after which this grid that was each stuffed with less-than-sparkling fill *and* clued arduous. It simply wasn’t my day. Ooh, sorry: LIMONCELLO. I do like that (each as fill and as beverage). Ultimately, it simply felt like there was no consideration given to what it might really feel like to unravel this factor. If you are gonna put me by means of the wringer, at the very least give me a prize for my perseverance. 

Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld 

P.S. value noting / confessing that I as soon as revealed a puzzle with unclued theme solutions, and that PROVOLONE was really a kind of solutions (!?). My themers had been extra within the “actual issues clued wackily” vein, so the sense of the reply was actually there within the clue. Anyway, it is extremely attainable that many solvers did not get pleasure from my puzzle, the way in which I did not get pleasure from this one. It occurs.

[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]



[ad_2]

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here