![magic the gathering – MTG: “Up to One Creature …” Creature is returned to proprietor’s hand, does it fizzle? magic the gathering – MTG: “Up to One Creature …” Creature is returned to proprietor’s hand, does it fizzle?](https://thefuntrove.com/wp-content/uploads/https://cdn.sstatic.net/Sites/boardgames/Img/apple-touch-icon@2.png?v=a8092236f814)
[ad_1]
Board & Card Games Stack Exchange is a query and reply website for individuals who like enjoying board video games, designing board video games or modifying the principles of current board video games. It solely takes a minute to enroll.
Anybody can ask a query
Anybody can reply
The greatest solutions are voted up and rise to the highest
Asked
Viewed
9 instances
So I do know a spell will fizzle if its goal is returned handy earlier than the spell resolves. However, if a spell specifies “Up to 1” goal, then will it nonetheless fizzle? Since even when the unique goal is returned, 0 is a sound “Up to 1” decision.
The card in query is: Banishing Slash
Even if the goal was returned handy, will the second half resolve and create a 2/2 token?
keeb is a brand new contributor to this website. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
No, when you select a goal and the goal is now not authorized because the spell begins to resolve, it is not going to resolve and you’ll not get a token.
This is defined in one of many card’s rulings:
You might forged Banishing Slash with out selecting a goal. If you do, and also you management each an artifact and an enchantment because it resolves, you may simply create a Samurai token. However, when you do select a goal and that concentrate on is an unlawful goal as Banishing Slash tries to resolve, Banishing Slash will not resolve and none of its results will occur. The unlawful goal will not be destroyed and you will not create a Samurai token.
You should log in to reply this query.
Not the reply you are searching for? Browse different questions tagged .
[ad_2]